In November, my friend Charlotte passed away. Today is her birthday. I was asked to say a few remarks at her memorial service last January. I think it’s appropriate to share what I said back then today, on her birthday.
Charlotte Ellis started out in my life as a client. One of those clients who don’t just demand, but expect a high level of service and excellence. It was an expectation she had, but never articulated. At least directly. Shortly after I was introduced to her I think she made her standards clear to me while consulting over the phone on the status of a project. She adeptly pointed out that the success of the agency I worked for, and my personal success were closely connected to her professional success. And if she looked good to her bosses, she would make sure I looked good to mine. It was a mutually beneficial arrangement, really, where she taught me that I was never to present a problem without a solution, and if I had a solution, then why bother presenting the problem. Just provide an update on the solution, and then let’s get down to the real business of the day – What is David Sedaris’ next book, and is he going on tour? If you had a dinner party with any authors you could get to the table, would you go the NPR supers-star status route, or more of the Nuevo-Southern writer direction? If you have a name that forms a picture, like Misty Dawn Clymer, or forms alliteration, as in Rebecca Revels, don’t you think you’re destined to rise to the top of the beauty pageant circuit?
Pondering these important questions, Charlotte became more than a client, she became my friend. Charlotte new the value of friendship, and I treasured that in her, well after she was no longer my client. To her, friendship was the ultimate wealth. After sharing with her a story I had written about celebrating a close friendship of mine, she wrote to me, “Okay, this made me cry. I don’t take friendships for granted – friends aren’t that easy to come by.”
For Charlotte, though, friends were easy to come by. She had many friends. Many old, dear friends. Every time I would meet up with her at convention, she was always introducing me to “an old friend.” She had no new friends. When her friends would finally meet, it would thrill her to simply sit back and watch the dynamics unfold. She’d say, “See, I just knew you would love each other. Isn’t this the best?” I often felt nothing would thrill her more than to assemble all of her old friends together in one room. Now, we are all finally here today, without Charlotte in her physical form. I can feel Charlotte here with us in my heart. She is here, and I’m certain she is whispering, “This is the best time.”
It’s ironically dramatic that we’re here, many of us meeting for the first time. But then Charlotte loved irony, and she loved a touch of juicy drama.
* * * * *
Irony and juicy drama fill the American Beauty Pageant scene. Back in 2002, when Misty Dawn and Rebecca Revels were stealing the headlines, Charlotte would forward me links to breaking news stories. Often two or three times a day. Sometimes, she would even call, telling me to tune in to WNCU over the internet RIGHT NOW! “You’re gonna love this,” she said. “This is the best. Rebecca Revels resigned as Miss North Carolina because her former boyfriend informed pageant officials he had inappropriate (read topless) photos of her, which he took. Apparently without her knowing. As a result, the crown goes to Misty Dawn, first runner-up. And if you think it can’t get juicier than this, after resigning, Rebecca decided she didn’t want to resign, and is now claiming she was intimidated into her resignation by the folks at the Miss North Carolina pageant. But they’ve told her the crown has already gone to Misty Dawn. Well, Rebecca is Lumbee Indian, and she is the first Native American to get the Miss North Carolina crown. Her platform was tribal rights, which I’m sure wasn’t very popular on the pageant circuit, and now the entire Lumbee Indian tribe is crying foul. Anyway, she has decided to sue for the crown, and the court order just came down stating that until this is all sorted out, they will both be recognized as Miss North Carolina. We have two Miss North Carolinas! How does this happen?”
“I’m googling right now,” I said to Charlotte, as I listened to her on the phone.
“By the way,” she said. “I love the fact that Google is now a verb. How a startup corporation can turn their name into a verb astounds me, but that’s a topic for another time. Right now, we need to figure out will Rebecca and Misty Dawn go on appearances together? Or will they have two separate schedules? Will they literally share the crown, or will they make two? And can you imagine the scheduling nightmare taking place in the Miss North Carolina office right now. All of this is uncharted territory, and with the Miss America Pageant only weeks away, how will they introduce them – the Misses North Carolina or the Miss North Carolinas? But what I really want to know through all this is how can someone with a name like Rebecca Revels get the crown in the first place? What is the world coming to?”
Charlotte was practically leaping through the phone. “I know I should be focused on my work, but this is a historic moment. North Carolina will now be known as the state with two Miss North Carolinas. The first state in the union!”
So many of Charlottes interests came crashing together in this intersection of American culture. It had all the rush of a fluffy crisis communications exercise, with interesting characters in dramatic situations where things happen to them. Unfortunate, unexpected things. And while contemplating whether the situation was a flaw, or a beauty mark on the underbelly of feminism, Charlotte’s Southern pride managed to ring true, as it often did in every situation she encountered.
* * * * *
We talked often during pageant season. Sometimes several times a week. One year, she sighed into the phone, “Why couldn’t I have been born Autumn Sunrise? I mean, I would at least sound articulate in the interview, and I could have a real platform.”
“Charlotte,” I said. “What would you do after you got the crown?”
“I suppose you’re right,” she said. “It is, sort of, all downhill from there. You don’t see many Misty Dawns at the corporate executive level.”
* * * * *
In April 2004, I was watching the Miss USA pageant with a group of friends. During an interview with Miss South Carolina, who claimed to be a healing species advocate, the host asked what it means to be a healing species advocate.
“It actually takes stray animals,” said Miss South Carolina on live National TV, “actually stray dogs, and stray children, and brings them together and teaches them love and compassion, so, it's just a wonderful thing.”
Eleven o’clock at night, I reached for the phone and dialed Charlotte.
“I’m so glad you called,” This was how she started any phone conversation. “I’ve been wondering when you would call.”
“Stray children?” I asked.
“So you heard it, too. Thank God you caught that,” she said. “I truly had thought I made the stray children part up. Do you think she is advocating that we spay and neuter children?”
“If not,” I replied, “that seems like a plan to control the stray children population.”
“And why,” she asked without missing a beat, “is Miss South Carolina always putting her hands on her hips. She looks like a hunchback whose hunch has fallen. (I would say ‘hump’, but that seems impolite.)”
Through the years, Charlotte and I had an ongoing commentary on beauty launchings today’s young women on every path to nowhere, much faster than intelligence or creativity. We could have easily transcribed our conversations and titled them “Fate of the American Beauty Queen.”
* * * * *
I think Fate of the American Beauty Queen had all the elements that were worthy of wrapping one’s self in. Drama, romance, glamour, mystery, a revealing theme, intrigue, insight into the human condition, and of course, irony.
All these elements, she loved. All the elements found in a really good book. She loved her books, and the stories contained within. She urged me to write more, at times my number one fan, pumping me up when I myself saw only a blank sheet of paper. When I’d tell her about what was going on in my life, she’d say, “Don’t tell me. Write about it. I want to read it.” She was convinced one day I’d be hosting that dinner party of NPR superstars, and to her, it was enough to read the story of how the evening would unfold. She really had no desire to be there – she wanted to read about it and imagine for herself.
Over the years, and always at the constant prodding of Charlotte, I’ve invested a lot of time and energy into my writing, and I’ve learned there are writers, wanna-be writers, and writer readers. Writers write like alcoholics drink. Writer wanna-bes think if they have the right fancy pen and the right journal, they will become a writer. And then there are writer readers, who could be writers, but are completely content just reading, absorbing, analyzing, and enjoying. These are the people writers write for. With her dreams of one day creating a non-profit organization to help struggling, emerging writers—particularly southern writers, many might have thought Charlotte was a wanna-be writer, but she really was a writer reader. I once sent her an essay asking if she would copy edit it. She was ecstatic. She sent it back, marked up with so much red ink, the only thing missing was the tape outlining the body. It was flagged with a note, “Wonderful. Simply wonderful.”
While she possessed all the skills and talents needed to be a writer, for whatever reason, she was content just sitting on the sidelines, watching the process unfold. Much like what would happen when she gathered her friends together.
While Charlotte loved her books and the stories within, she loved even more sitting in her spot at Quail Ridge Bookstore, listening to her favorite writers read their own words, making them come to life. Ultimately, though, what thrilled her to no end was when she actually got to meet her favorite writers and interact with them. To her, a great writer was a Hollywood heavyweight, and the fact that an author with as much talent as Haven Kimmel actually took the time to have dinner with her and a group of friends made Charlotte feel as if she was sitting back stage of the creative process, enjoying a perspective no one else could get. It was a highlight in her life.
To Charlotte, every character in every book grew to be an old friend. And when she would read the words on a page, she would relate to the writer as if they were an old friend. She scrutinized the pages of every book she opened, admiring the craft it took to bring it together. And then she would introduce all of us to her friends in a story.
Charlotte deeply admired creativity. When creativity was combined with intelligence and insight, it made her jealous. After sending her a few vacation photos, she wrote back, and I can hear her saying these words in her slow, gentle, thoughtful voice: “I’m starting to get annoyed with all this talent in one person. I love your photography as much as I love your writing, and it’s irritating the hell out of me. With great admiration, Charlotte.”
Spoken like a true Southern Lady.
Of all the writers she knew and interacted with, the one she admired the most was her brother, Andy. I always got the sense that while she claimed to love everything I sent her to read, it was not David Sadaris, or Haven Kimmel she would hold me up against. Rather it was her brother. She was very proud of Andy’s accomplishments in his life, and if you knew Charlotte, then you knew Andy Ellis was the most talented and creative person in the world.
* * * * *
Charlotte was creative in the most magical of ways. Certainly, professionally, she has been celebrated for her contributions to an entire industry. But it’s on the personal level where her creativity was spellbinding. If you were Charlotte’s friend, then you honestly felt she didn’t have any other friends in the world, and you were, by far, her best friend. A friend of Charlotte’s received books that she found inspiring. Copies of articles she knew would amuse you. It was as if Charlotte went through her day, looking for ways to remind friends she was thinking of them. Sometimes I think that was her full-time job.
While I won’t pretend to claim that I was Charlotte’s best friend even for a minute, I can say that she grew in my heart to be one of the major characters of my life, as she did with so many others.
If we were to stitch together all the stories where Charlotte made a profound difference in the lives of others, we would have an epic novel revolving around a great heroine. Probably named, Autumn Sunrise. She would touch the lives of many people on very deep levels, no matter how she knew them. She would be a muse, an educator, a motivator, and an innovator. Thoughtful and articulate, she would be accomplished in her field—celebrated, even. And, she would have a heart of gold bigger than any other.
Filled with many old friends, I’m sure it’s a book Charlotte would have loved, and one she would have convinced each of us we all had to read—that we would get something out of it. This character, Autumn Sunrise, she’d say, is amazing. And we all would think, “If it’s good enough for Charlotte, then it’s good enough for me.” We’d read the book, we’d fall in love with Autumn, and then in the final chapter when Autumn’s sun has finally set, we’d all be sad there are no more pages to turn.
Charlotte would sit there, giggling to herself. She’d say, “Isn’t it the best?”
Labels: Happenings, Memoir, writing